Look closely enough at Elizabeth Holmes and surely something will give her away. That is the tantalising promise of You Can See Everything.
In a viral scene from the documentary, Nathan Fielder locks eyes with the disgraced Theranos founder in a truly bizarre interaction. He looks almost feral with curiosity; she stares back, eerily impassive, her big blue eyes and rosy, mouse-like features refusing to flinch. Neither seems willing to blink, let alone look away.
The staring contest becomes a battleground of sorts. A stand-off that co-director Lance Oppenheim brings us into the heart of with tight close-ups, daring us, as the entire film does, to unpick the mystery of Elizabeth Holmes.
The close-up has always invited this kind of scrutiny. The Hungarian film theorist Béla Balázs famously regarded it as a magnifying glass for the soul, arguing that stripping away a character’s surroundings brings us into intimate contact with their face, making the smallest expression seem significant and revealing thoughts that words could conceal. It carries an almost magical promise of access, as though a sufficiently prolonged look might expose some hidden psychological truth.

Cinema history offers plenty of moments that seem to honour that promise – and others that deliberately complicate it. In The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928), Carl Theodor Dreyer turned Maria Falconetti’s face into an emotional landscape, capturing anguish and spiritual conviction with extraordinary intensity. Ingmar Bergman’s Persona (1966) took things somewhere more unsettling. In one of arthouse cinema’s most famous images, he merges half of Liv Ullmann’s face with half of Bibi Andersson’s, creating a single, uncanny composite. Rather than exposing a fixed truth, the close-up suggests that identity itself is fragile – or even an illusion.
Abbas Kiarostami’s Close-Up (1990) offers another vital complication. Following Hossain Sabzian, a cinephile put on trial for impersonating filmmaker Mohsen Makhmalbaf, Kiarostami turns his camera on the impostor in search of his motives – only to find that proximity blurs the line between deception and sincerity. Sabzian performed another man’s identity, yet his longing for recognition is entirely genuine. Intimacy, Kiarostami suggests, does not necessarily produce clarity.
Fielder and Oppenheim’s You Can See Everything operates with a similar tension. The camera lingers on Holmes, coaxing us to believe that proximity might yield understanding even as her carefully maintained composure frustrates the search. Yet in doing so, the film quietly turns that scrutiny back on us, exposing our own voyeuristic appetite to play armchair detective. Her face becomes both a site of intense scrutiny and an impenetrable surface. Because a face is not a confession. An expression can be performed, a hesitation misinterpreted, a blank, unblinking stare loaded with meanings that may not be there at all.
What makes Holmes such a particular subject is that her face was once part of the machinery of persuasion. Her carefully cultivated public image helped give Theranos its aura of credibility – a Steve Jobsian sense of magnetic forward momentum. Now, that same image is subjected to relentless examination. In a culture saturated with curated personal brands, viral micro-expression breakdowns and relentless self-performance, the distinction between being watched and being understood has rarely felt more important. We may know Holmes’s face intimately, but that familiarity can easily be mistaken for knowledge of the person behind it.
Perhaps that is why she makes for such a compelling figure on screen. We watch in the hope of discovering something that will settle the question of who she really is. But You Can See Everything understands that the close-up can only take us so far – and might even take us further away.








Leave a Reply