Extra Geography – Film Review

Four gold stars in a row, representing a rating or review.

The world of a teenage girl is rarely a straightforward one. Your friends can feel more significant than almost anything else in your life; every minor humiliation becomes catastrophic, and the prospect of adulthood seems impossibly distant but urgently close. Molly Manners’ Extra Geography captures this period with a combination of sharp humour, awkwardness, and tenderness.

The film follows best friends Minna (Galaxie Clear) and Flic (Marni Duggan), two ambitious and academic teenagers at an all-girls boarding school in England. More interested in their studies than boys, the pair decide that their summer project should be something a little more worldly: they are going to learn how to fall in love.

Their chosen target is their geography teacher, Miss Delavigne (Alice Englert). What initially seems like a silly experiment progressively exposes the cracks in a friendship that has always depended on the girls being perfectly matched at everything that they do. As they become increasingly aware of boys, sex, ambition, and the possibility of lives beyond the school gates, the closeness that once made them inseparable begins to feel fragile.

Two girls in blue sweaters leaning on a stone wall with a historic building in the background under a cloudy sky.
Flic (Marni Duggan) and Minna (Galaxie Clear) in Extra Geography. Photo: Matt Towers

Clear and Duggan are superb in their feature debuts Their friendship is funny, affectionate, and faintly suffocating. There is a familiar and almost telepathic quality to their dynamic: they finish each other’s thoughts, compete with one another, and have constructed their identities around being a pair. Beneath the jokes, however, is an uncomfortable truth. When two people grow up together, forming an individual identity can have the side effect of forcing distance, and ultimately growing apart.

That tension plays out throughout the film. Flic and Minna are constantly measuring themselves against each other academically, socially, and romantically, whilst remaining insistent that their friendship is more important than everything else. Their competitiveness is funny until it isn’t, and Manners understands how quickly affection can become envy, and then resentment.

There is an enjoyably deadpan quality to Miriam Battye’s script, which treats the girls’ bizarre plans with the exact level of seriousness that the girls themselves would. The absurdity of two teenagers deciding to deliberately fall in love sits within an understanding of the earnestness with which teenagers approach their own lives. What seems ridiculous to watch as the viewer feels completely logical to the fourteen-year-old brain.

The film has a heightened visual identity that distinguishes it from the many coming-of-age stories that have come before it. The ornate title cards, classical touches, and stylised presentation create a world that feels slightly removed from reality (much like the world of a teenage girl). Yet the film never loses sight of the emotional reality underneath this style.

Extra Geography recognises that some of the most painful relationships of our lives are not necessarily romantic ones. There is a particular heartbreak in watching a friendship change when neither person has necessarily done anything wrong. People grow in different directions, and priorities change. Eventually, the person who once knew you better than anyone else gradually becomes someone you no longer quite recognise.

Two teenage girls in school uniforms standing with their arms crossed, holding green folders, in front of a map-covered wall.
Minna (Galaxie Clear) and Flic (Marni Duggan) in Extra Geography. Photo: Matt Towers

There are moments when the film’s heightened tone can feel a little too mannered, and its narrative occasionally leans into common conventions of the coming-of-age genre. But Manners’ confidence behind the camera, combined with the extraordinary chemistry between Clear and Duggan, carries the film through these imperfections.

What remains is an unusually perceptive portrait of girlhood: funny, awkward, obsessive and occasionally cruel, but also deeply affectionate. Extra Geography understands that growing up isn’t only about discovering who you are. For all its eccentricity, that is what makes the film so relatable. The project to fall in love may be fictional, but the experience at its centre is universal: the dawning realisation that childhood is ending, and what comes next is outside of your control.

Manners’ feature debut is a funny, and bittersweet portrait of friendship, ambition, and the process of becoming yourself. It is a film that shows us that sometimes the hardest part of getting older is realising that you may eventually outgrow the person you once thought you would grow alongside forever.


Extra Geography is in cinemas October 2

Check out our socials

Find Us Online

Join the Conversation

What did you think? We’d love to hear your take – share your thoughts in the comments below.

Leave a Reply


Recommended Articles